I'll throw my 2 cent opinion into this subject.......:nuts:
I've got a wall full of plugs, Bombers of every size & color, fed Fins, Stan Gibbs woodies, soft plastics of every variety on different weight jigheads, bucktails dressed with soft plastics....etc....etc.....
Every single one of them either can, or has caught a fish at one point or another, some I've taken a liking too for whatever reason, and many hang in the garage collecting dust.
There have been days I've stood in the suds throwing everything I had in the bag, others around me hooked up, and I got skunked, just the same I can recall on a couple occasions when I was hooking up with one after another, and everyone else was looking over my shoulder to see what I was using cause they couldn't catch a cold with what they had tied on.....
Certain plugs will work in certain conditions, sometimes the fish go after just the small one's and won't touch a 7" Bomber, other days they favor a certain color, or just soft plastics. Most often, trying to catch a striper with an artificial bait is much like trying to feed a toddler in a high chair something he doesn't like to eat, and it can get very frustrating....
What I've found to be the best way to fill a lure bag for surf and jetty plugging is this....
Get yourself a couple packs of Storm Shads in 4", Bunker color, white, and pink. Depending on the weight line and outfit you are using, a couple of Stan Gibbs or similar wood plugs, a couple of swimmers, and a couple surface poppers, fill in the open slots with a couple different color Bombers or similar mid water swimmers, and don't forget something metal either.
As for color, match the hatch is the basic rule, if the bass are chasing Herring in the spring, throw stuff that looks and swims like a herring, in the fall it's bunker and mullet. If they are chasing shiners or the water is real dirty throw the metal.
The important thing is to not get stuck on just one thing, if something isn't working after a dozen casts, change up to something else.
Like the rest of us, over time you will end up with a wall full of lures, some you will like, and others will collect dust....that's surf fishing.....:huh: